Oh, the ’90s niche — I’m going to show you two ideas to update this very common issue!

Before & After: Virtual Rendering

A niche, or recessed alcove, was a common feature in homes in the ’90s and early 2000s. Whether it was meant to add character or serve a function—like this one, built for when our TVs used to be 18 inches deep—the question now is: how do we address these very awkward spaces?

Option 1
The fireplace is the natural focal point of this room. If you like a more traditional style that feels cohesive with the home’s architecture, I would keep the box moulding look, but with a modern twist. To achieve this look, I would cover the niche with drywall. Then use picture moulding, secured with construction adhesive and brad nails, to mimic the original fireplace surround style. To draw your eye up and make the space feel more centered and cohesive, I would use a moody paint color like Benjamin Moore Midnight Blue.

Option 2
If your style leans more modern farmhouse/cottage core then I would use stone to introduce a more natural element to the space that is loaded with texture and character. Achieving this look is a little more complex, but totally doable! First you need to frame out a new fireplace surround that is flush with the face of the fireplace and goes all the way to the ceiling. Once everything is framed, I would use cement board to close it off and give the stone a sturdy surface to adhere to. Then use mortar to attach the stones to the cement board (there’s TONS of free tutorials on YouTube to walk you through this if you want to DIY). I would choose a neutral stone with light mortar to tie in with the neutral color scheme of the furniture. Adding a wooden mantel above the fireplace is a great way to add more warmth, texture, and balance to the space as well.

In both cases, I added floor-to-ceiling curtains to bring in warmth, texture, and visual balance. The furnishings stay neutral, with pops of contrast through accent pieces like throw pillows, blankets, and artwork. Overall, the room takes on a completely different feel—one of intentional design and a cozy living space the whole family can enjoy.

Make sure you’re following along on Instagram for weekly room transformation ideas! I’ve sourced both high-end and budget-friendly furniture for this space. You can shop the links below or on my Amazon and LTK storefronts. Use the link below to submit your space to be considered to be featured next week!

Want to be featured on a future Spruce My Space?

Every week I take photos of YOUR spaces in your homes and photoshop how I would design and decorate them! If you’d like to submit a photo of your space for a chance to be featured next, click the button below!

CLICK TO SUBMIT YOUR SPACE